Rick's Plumbing vs Robinson's Painting & Home Improvement for small kitchen updates
The differences that matter
- What kind of "update" you need. Rick's is a plumbing specialist built around sink, faucet, and leak work in the kitchen, while Robinson's treats kitchen updates as one piece of a broader carpentry, electrical, drywall, and painting job.
- Track record size. Rick's has 1,297 reviews to draw on versus Robinson's 146, giving Rick's a much larger sample even though both average 5 stars.
- Who oversees the job. Rick's sends named technicians like Jonathan, Lee, Nick, or Patrick to diagnose and fix the specific problem, while Robinson personally visits projects multiple times to inspect progress.
- Urgency vs scope. Rick's explicitly handles emergency weekend and weeknight calls for things like leaks, whereas Robinson's work reads as scheduled, multi-day home improvement projects.
- Pricing posture. Rick's advertises transparent pricing with published discounts, while Robinson's is positioned as premium and not budget-focused, with customers accepting the higher cost for quality.
Side by side
- Google rating
- Rick's Plumbing Service, Inc.: 5 (1297 reviews)
- Robinson's Painting & Home Improvement LLC: 5 (146 reviews)
- Services
- Rick's Plumbing Service, Inc.: small kitchen updates, full kitchen remodel
- Robinson's Painting & Home Improvement LLC: countertop installation, kitchen design, full kitchen remodel
- Core trade focus
- Rick's Plumbing Service, Inc.: Plumbing: sinks, faucets, disposals, leaks, toilet repairs
- Robinson's Painting & Home Improvement LLC: Multi-trade home improvement: carpentry, electrical, drywall, painting, plus kitchen updates
- Project oversight style
- Rick's Plumbing Service, Inc.: Named technicians dispatched per service call
- Robinson's Painting & Home Improvement LLC: Owner Robinson personally checks in on projects as they progress
- Pricing position
- Rick's Plumbing Service, Inc.: Transparent, published pricing with discounts
- Robinson's Painting & Home Improvement LLC: Premium pricing, accepted by customers in exchange for redo-until-satisfied quality
- Verification
- Rick's Plumbing Service, Inc.: Google-verified
- Robinson's Painting & Home Improvement LLC: Google-verified
- Composite score
- Rick's Plumbing Service, Inc.: 95
- Robinson's Painting & Home Improvement LLC: 93
Within 3 points of each other, so treat them as effectively tied on overall quality. The choice below is about fit, not the score.
What reviewers say
Rick's Plumbing Service, Inc.
Reviewers consistently report arriving technicians who diagnose plumbing issues accurately, complete work quickly, and leave homes as clean as they found them. Staff like Jonathan, Lee, Nick, and Patrick are named repeatedly for friendliness and expertise; the business handles emergency calls on weekends and weeknights, and even tackles unusual problems without invasive solutions.
Kitchen sink and faucet installations, toilet repairs, and leak fixes dominate the work. Customers appreciate clear pricing upfront, willingness to offer temporary fixes, and follow-up when parts arrive. One reviewer noted a sink-opening mismatch during installation that Jonathan resolved patiently; no unresolved complaints appear in recent feedback.
Robinson's Painting & Home Improvement LLC
Robinson's earns universal five-star ratings for interior and exterior painting, with customers consistently praising the owner's hands-on involvement, skilled crew, and willingness to remake work until satisfied. The business handles painting as the core service but also performs carpentry, electrical work, drywall repair, and kitchen updates, earning trust through responsive communication and competitive pricing for the Fairfield area.
Owner Robinson visits projects regularly to inspect progress. Crews clean thoroughly, meet deadlines, and solve problems on the fly, such as coordinating structural repairs when issues arise. Repeat customers are common. The business is not positioned as budget-focused; reviewers understand and accept the premium pricing in exchange for quality and reliability.
Which should you pick?
Pick Rick's Plumbing Service, Inc. if
- A faucet, sink, or disposal in the kitchen is leaking, broken, or needs replacing and you want it handled fast, including weekends or evenings
- You want a huge track record to vet first: 1,297 reviews all landing at 5 stars is a lot of data to check
- You'd rather have upfront, published pricing than a custom project quote
Pick Robinson's Painting & Home Improvement LLC if
- The "update" is really cosmetic or structural: new cabinet trim, drywall patching, an outlet moved, a fresh coat of paint, done together
- You want the owner physically checking on the work as it happens instead of a dispatched technician
- You're comfortable paying a premium in exchange for a crew that will redo work until you're happy with it
Verdict
Match the business to the job, not the score. If the kitchen problem is plumbing, a leaking faucet, a sink that needs replacing, a disposal on the fritz, Rick's Plumbing Service is the direct fit, backed by a much larger review history and explicit emergency response. If the "update" is more cosmetic or structural, new trim, a patched wall, a repainted cabinet run, possibly paired with an outlet move, Robinson's Painting & Home Improvement fits better, with the owner personally overseeing the work and a crew used to juggling multiple trades on one small job. Both hold 5-star averages, so the deciding factor is what kind of work the kitchen actually needs.
Need help choosing which remodeler?
Describe your kitchen project once and compare quotes from kitchen remodeler in Connecticut.
Enquiries submitted through our contact and quote forms may be shared with partner providers who can perform the work, and we may earn a referral fee from those referrals. Our rankings and scores are determined only by our published method and are never influenced by referral fees.
Frequently asked questions
- Which business is better for a leaky kitchen faucet or a sink that needs replacing?
- Rick's Plumbing Service. That's core plumbing work, and the data shows named technicians handling exactly this, including emergency weekend calls, with transparent pricing.
- Which is better if the kitchen update includes new cabinets, drywall, or an electrical outlet?
- Robinson's Painting & Home Improvement. It operates as a multi-trade crew covering carpentry, electrical, and drywall alongside kitchen updates, with the owner personally inspecting the work.
- Does either business specialize only in kitchens?
- No. Rick's is a general plumbing company where kitchen sink and faucet work is one common job type. Robinson's is a painting and home improvement company where kitchen updates are one of several services alongside carpentry and electrical.
- Which has the larger review history to check?
- Rick's Plumbing, with 1,297 reviews versus Robinson's 146, though both sit at a 5-star average.